LV Breakers, Switches, Fuses and Contactors: IEC 60947 Coordination
Distinguish breaker making, breaking and withstand ratings; reproduce assumed grading-band and cable-stress checks while requiring exact manufacturer combinatio
1. Separate interruption, withstand and coordination
A fault study, a device interrupting rating and a coordination claim answer different questions. The study establishes prospective duty and branch current for a declared source configuration. The rating states performance under specified conditions. Coordination assesses how devices and the protected equipment behave together. An ACB or MCCB, switch-disconnector, fuse and contactor cannot be interchanged merely because their current labels match. A contactor controls the motor circuit and needs an appropriate short-circuit protective device. An overload relay and its trip class do not provide the contactor with an independent short-circuit breaking capacity.
IEC 60947-2:2024; IEC 60947-3; IEC 60947-4-1:2023 + COR1:2026; IEC 60269
2. Read the rated quantities on the correct basis
Read the manufacturer's rated operating voltage, frequency, poles, trip unit and installation conditions alongside each current value. Insulation voltage and impulse withstand are not substitutes for operating voltage or interrupting duty. The breaking and short-time withstand quantities in the table are RMS quantities on their declared basis, while making capacity is a peak quantity. Do not convert the prospective symmetrical current into a peak using only a sinusoidal factor: the applicable fault asymmetry and equipment duty must be considered. An assembly's peak withstand rating describes a different object and function from a breaker's making rating.
| Quantity | Declared role | Rating basis |
|---|---|---|
| Icu | Ultimate breaking capacity | RMS |
| Ics | Service breaking capacity | RMS |
| Icw | Short-time withstand, with duration | RMS |
| Icm | Short-circuit making capacity | peak |
| Ipk | Assembly peak withstand; separate from breaker making | peak |
3. Distinguish selectivity from tested back-up protection
Selectivity aims to isolate the faulty downstream circuit while retaining other supplies. It can be limited to a declared current range or be total on the manufacturer's stated basis. Back-up or cascading protection uses a coordinated association, often involving upstream current limitation, to meet a duty that the downstream device could not meet independently. One claim does not establish the other. Both can be claimed together only when the exact association and conditions are documented. At high fault current, independent time-current curves may omit the dynamic interaction; obtain applicable combination data and tests.
4. Use timing bands and complete clearing times
Compare the latest downstream total-clearing boundary with the earliest irreversible upstream trip response for the same fault and actual branch currents. A relay operating curve alone may omit breaker opening and arcing time. Conversely, a supplied total-clearing curve already includes clearing and must not receive that delay again. The upstream boundary must describe the relevant non-trip or irreversible response, not just its later total interruption. Include declared tolerances, sensor behavior, instantaneous overrides and any memory or reset effects. Nominal lines with a visual gap are insufficient evidence when tolerance bands overlap.
5. Reproduce two assumed grading points
The table is a deliberately assumed example at the stated operating voltage, not a catalog of real breaker performances. The upstream input is its earliest irreversible trip response; the downstream input is its latest total clearing. The required interval is an educational assumption, not a universal grading rule. The lower-current point passes that interval, whereas the higher-current point fails even a non-overlap check. No interpolation between the points is authorized. Repeat the analysis throughout the relevant current range and source modes, including minimum faults, instantaneous transitions and earth-fault elements.
Ue = 400 V AC; required interval = 0.050 s
| Assumed branch fault | Downstream maximum total clearing | Upstream minimum irreversible response | Available interval |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 kA | 0.120 s | 0.180 s | 0.060 s |
| 20 kA | 0.100 s | 0.080 s | −0.020 s |
6. Check cable thermal stress independently
For the declared copper/PVC construction, conductor size and initial/final temperature assumptions, the adiabatic screening inequality below compares the current-squared time integral with the conductor limit. Its unit is current squared multiplied by time, not joules; an energy in joules would additionally require resistance. The material factor is conditional on conductor and insulation temperatures, and is not a universal value for every cable. The two let-through inputs are assumptions, not manufacturer's measured curves. For a current-limiting breaker or fuse, use documented total-clearing let-through data for the actual voltage and prospective current.
t ≤ 5 s (adiabatic model)
| Input or derived limit | Value |
|---|---|
| S | 25 mm² |
| k | 115 A·√s/mm² |
| θ_initial | 70 °C |
| θ_final | 160 °C |
| k²S² | 8265625 A²s |
| Assumed total-clearing stress | Below conductor limit |
|---|---|
| 3000000 A²s | ✓ |
| 12000000 A²s | ✗ |
7. Keep motor-starter coordination application-specific
Motor-starter coordination concerns the tested association of short-circuit protection, contactor and overload function under the declared test conditions. It is not a selectivity category between two feeder breakers. The less restrictive coordination outcome may require repair or replacement after a fault; the more restrictive outcome permits further service under the manufacturer's stated inspection and maintenance provisions, including permitted easily separable contact welding. It does not guarantee zero maintenance. Motor starting, transition currents, duty cycle and thermal protection remain additional checks. Match the actual starter topology and equipment references rather than transferring a result from another arrangement.
| Quantity | Declared role |
|---|---|
| Type 1 | Repair or replacement may be needed |
| Type 2 | Further use subject to declared inspection/maintenance; permitted separable welding |
8. Require exact combination evidence
A valid combination record identifies the protective devices, fuse class and link, contactor, overload relay, trip unit, setting group, firmware where relevant, poles, operating voltage and available fault current. Preserve the manufacturer's table revision and its limitations. Check whether neutral poles and accessories alter the declared arrangement. Thermal cable protection, busbar electrodynamic withstand, motor protection and contactor survivability are related but separate acceptance decisions. Neither the cable example nor a successful single timing point proves the complete panel. Do not use either as an incident-energy calculation or an approval to increase intentional delay.
9. Keep the study and procurement records connected
Freeze the SLD revision, source operating cases, current basis, settings and manufacturer evidence with the report and RFQ. Use the existing feeder timing example, short-circuit method limits, motor-starting guide and network-validation workflow for the upstream evidence chain. A family match in the catalog is a research relationship, not proof of an approved combination. Changed transformer impedance, parallel operation, generator contribution or replacement trip units can invalidate an earlier result even when the equipment names remain familiar.
10. Primary sources and capability boundary
The cited manufacturer guides support the distinction between ratings, selectivity, back-up associations, cable stress and starter coordination. Public IEC pages confirm the relevant equipment scopes and the listed corrigendum; their existence is not a claim that full licensed clauses were reviewed. The worked arithmetic is Reference-Tested. No OEM curve library, approved settings, full-range selectivity, tested panel compliance or independently validated production coordination engine is established by these examples. Installation review, exact manufacturer declarations and commissioning remain necessary project evidence, retained with their actual revision and limits.
- Siemens — SIVACON S8 planning manual 2025, assembly rated peak withstand Ipk
- IEC 60947-2:2024 — public equipment scope
- IEC 60947-4-1:2023 — public scope, includes COR1:2026
- Schneider Electric — Icm, peak making capacity
- ABB — Icu, Ics, Icw and Icm definitions
- Schneider Electric — circuit-breaker coordination and back-up
- Schneider Electric — cable short-circuit withstand and k factors
- Schneider Electric — Type 2 coordination
- IEC 60364-4-43:2023 — public scope, overcurrent protection
- Scope
- MV Feeder Protection Settings: 50/51, 67, 79 and IEC 60255 Evidence
- Industrial Motor Selection: IEC 60034 Ratings, Starting and IE Efficiency
- IEC 60909 Short-Circuit Calculations: Worked Check, Edition and Model Limits
- Grounding Transformers (Zigzag ZN) and Neutral Earthing Resistors (NGR): Sizing & Fault Duty